Score: 3

"Lacks creativity"

submission: Pokemon - Left 4 Dead

date: November 24, 2009

Outside of the original concept of "L4D/Pokemon" fusion, this had little to no creativity whatsoever. The animation was weak, the pacing was terrible, there was little variety in the attacks (and attacks almost always moved to half health)... little seems to been have put into this. I know the easy kills were "quick and to the point," but it only made things weaker.
This is purely riding upon a wave of "I like Left 4 Dead" and "I like Pokemon" support.

Score: 5

"Come Clarity Collab pt. 2"

submission: *Prayer*

date: November 17, 2009

Unfortunately this is a sequel in every way (I jumped the gun on the CCC, hence the positive review). I wasn't surprised at all to see at least one artist from it. You could have copied and pasted any song into here and it would have worked just as well. In fact, I've rewatched twice it with different music (Lamb of God's "Redneck," but surprisingly the one that fit best was Bon Jovi performing an acoustic version of "Living on a Prayer").
Some of the animation was good, but based on the failed premise and a pretty mundane video, I can't give this any more than a five.

Score: 5

"One of the three deadly flash sins"

submission: -Reminiscence-

date: November 13, 2009

Egoraptor inspired movies, sprites, and really long tween movies. This movie was predictable, slow paced, and it had AFI and My Chemical Romance. Sorry, but this movie wasn't for me.

Score: 5

"Well..."

submission: Slave and Master

date: February 10, 2009

Schleif basically brought up all the points I had, but I have one other thing. Learning to scream takes awhile, learning how to record it properly is even harder. However, regardless of the skill, you ought to turn down your vocal tracks and raise the instrumentals. There needs to be a proper balance, without it even accomplished vocalists sound worse.

Score: 1

"Mmm... I'm going to have to agree"

submission: Comfort of Myself

date: February 10, 2009

It was slow to build, there is no musicianship, the vocals are annoying, and it just didn't work.
Screaming isn't simple, but even without a sore throat I could not see how this would be good. Screaming and a capella do not mix well, and this track proved it.

Score: 8

"Not too bad"

submission: Paint It Black (Metal)

date: February 10, 2009

I had some reservations against a metal cover of what in my opinion is a near perfect song, but you managed to do a pretty good job of it. I'd be interested to see how a full-scale version turns out.
I say go for it.